Mailing List flyrotary@lancaironline.net Message #30227
From: John Slade <sladerj@bellsouth.net>
Subject: RE: [FlyRotary] Re: Why do this? / was Another Rotary failure.
Date: Tue, 14 Feb 2006 23:54:08 -0500
To: Rotary motors in aircraft <flyrotary@lancaironline.net>
Message
a well maintained certified type engine is light years ahead in reliability.   
Sorry, Rusty, but I've got to take issue with that.
I got into the rotary not for the challenge, and certainly not for the cash savings.  I've seen plenty of the former and little of the latter so far. The reason I wanted a rotary was first and foremost, increased reliability. Specifically a reduced chance of a catastrophic failure and stopped prop and better chance of making it to a field if something DID go wrong. The other reason was that I wanted more power at altitude.
 
I'm just now getting to the point that I'm ready to wear my "I love flying my rotary" badge. It's been a long haul, solving little problems one at a time, but because of the redundancy, it hasn't been a dangerous one.
 
We were just discussing this on the canard forum. Here's a snip of what I posted there on the same issue......
I wouldn't call it lack of confidence. It's more of an "acute awareness" that I admit to not having had when flying my Cherokee all over the East Coast. Obviously I did the usual off field training, PFLs etc and kept the issue in mind, but nowhere near as much as I do these days. Is that because the Rotary is more likely to let me down? Not really. In fact I think it's less likely to stop the prop than that old (2250 SMOH) O320 I was driving. The rotary engine isn't likely to fail internally and I have redundancy on almost all critical systems, so I'm probably more confident than I was. That is... if I'd thought about it as much in the Piper, which I didn't. In those days I'd bumble along cross country at 1000' without a care in the world. I don't do that any more, but it's not because of the rotary. Perhaps it's because of the increased landing speeds.
 
The first few flights were certainly adrenaline pushers, if not a little scary, but we pilot types thrive on adrenaline - right? I'm confident that I'm though the worst of the unique installation issues. The last few months have been plagued with little things - minor fuel leak, partially blocked filter, fuel pump ground, minor oil leak and, finally, minor coolant leak. Would you believe - a fully tightened brand new $30 AN swivel fitting leaking? , All little annoying stuff.
 
There have been zero issues that damaged the underwear or even changed the heart rate.
I'm confident that the "acute awareness" will settle down over time.

My 2c
John
Turbo Rotary Cozy IV
53.3 hrs.
Subscribe (FEED) Subscribe (DIGEST) Subscribe (INDEX) Unsubscribe Mail to Listmaster