Mailing List lml@lancaironline.net Message #42631
From: George Braly <gwbraly@gami.com>
Sender: <marv@lancaironline.net>
Subject: RE: [LML] TSIO550E: Oil Cooler Door Scoop to Help Cyl 2 Cooling (LIVP)
Date: Tue, 12 Jun 2007 00:43:37 -0400
To: <lml@lancaironline.net>
TSIO550E: Oil Cooler Door Scoop to Help Cyl 2 Cooling (LIV

Jeff,

 

What you did is just masking the real issue.

 

The real issue is that the bottom rear quadrant of cylinder fins on cylinder #2 is not getting air. 

 

And they CAN NOT get air without the more difficult baffling adjustment that you avoided.   It is a knuckle buster.

 

What you have done is to cool off #2 by about 10 degrees.

 

If you do this correctly,  it will drop #2 by about 25 to 35 degrees and it will become one of the cooler cylinders on the engine.

 

Number 2 can, will,  and does  go “out of round”  a bit because the lower set of cooling fins on the back side get almost no air flow from the normal baffling installation.  What you did does not address the “block” in the air flow that affects that issue.

 

Regards,  George

 


From: Lancair Mailing List [mailto:lml@lancaironline.net] On Behalf Of Jeffrey Liegner, MD
Sent: Monday, June 11, 2007 1:54 AM
To: lml@lancaironline.net
Subject: [LML] TSIO550E: Oil Cooler Door Scoop to Help Cyl 2 Cooling (LIVP)

 

I was recently given guidance to lower Cyl 2 temps to make the CHT grouping tighter and improve overall power options, particularly in climb.  The suggestion and demonstrated method was to cut a hole in the front wall of the oil cooler airbox to encourage air to get around the aft side of Cyl 2, and add a box to the opening (extending into the airbox in front of the oil cooler) so the ram air for the cylinder does not mix with the air heading through the oil cooler.  With the engine installed, this is a tough modification in a narrowed space, and my fingers/knuckles would take a beating if I tried this without removing the oil cooler en bloc from the back side of the engine.

 

Instead, I tried something different and created an alumimum bilayered flap/scoop coming off the oil cooler door, anchored via the same three oil cooler door hinge screws, to catch incoming air and divert more to the Cyl 2 aft side.

 

I should have taken a picture before I zipped up the cowl...sorry.  If there's an interest, I'll send it as an addendum.

 

The pre-installation temps were (level cruise):

Cyl 1   368     340

Cyl 2   394     364     Cyl 2 running hottest, a problem with full power climbs.

Cyl 3   356     332

Cyl 4   356     331

Cyl 5   346     331

Cyl 6   326     309

Diff HiLo       (68)    (55)

 

After installation of oil cooler door scoop (level cruise):

Cyl 1   339     334     346
Cyl 2        352     346     356
Cyl 3        330     328     340
Cyl 4        328     323     340
Cyl 5        330     330     337
Cyl 6        309     307     318

Diff HiLo       (43)    (39)    (38)

 

No change in oil temps observed.  Power settings were not matched pre- and post-.

 

I do not have climb out data yet, when the power settigns and temps are much higher and the airspeed is lower.

 

Looks like CHT#2 is a bit cooler with this simple mod.  Nicely, the more the oil door is open, the more the hinged aluminum piece takes a diverting bite of incoming rushing air.

 

I share this for those who might be curious.  Not very sophisticated, but my knuckles are not complaining. 

 

Jeff Liegner

N334P (LIVP)

Subscribe (FEED) Subscribe (DIGEST) Subscribe (INDEX) Unsubscribe Mail to Listmaster