X-Virus-Scanned: clean according to Sophos on Logan.com X-SpamCatcher-Score: 69 [XX] (100%) RECEIVED: IP not found on home country list Return-Path: Sender: To: lml Date: Fri, 22 Dec 2006 23:21:44 -0500 Message-ID: X-Original-Return-Path: Received: from mail17.syd.optusnet.com.au ([211.29.132.198] verified) by logan.com (CommuniGate Pro SMTP 5.1.3) with ESMTPS id 1703082 for lml@lancaironline.net; Fri, 22 Dec 2006 22:18:49 -0500 Received-SPF: none receiver=logan.com; client-ip=211.29.132.198; envelope-from=fredmoreno@optusnet.com.au Received: from fred (optussatellitebintb.22bjipb002.optus.net.au [59.154.24.148]) (authenticated sender fredmoreno) by mail17.syd.optusnet.com.au (8.13.1/8.13.1) with ESMTP id kBN3HdCS010525 for ; Sat, 23 Dec 2006 14:17:49 +1100 From: "Fred Moreno" X-Original-To: "Lancair Mail" Subject: System Reliability X-Original-Date: Sat, 23 Dec 2006 12:17:40 +0900 X-Original-Message-ID: <010501c72640$eedecdd0$c211140a@fred> MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/related; boundary="----=_NextPart_000_0106_01C7268C.5EC675D0" X-Priority: 3 (Normal) X-MSMail-Priority: Normal X-Mailer: Microsoft Outlook, Build 10.0.6626 X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V6.00.2900.3028 Importance: Normal This is a multi-part message in MIME format. ------=_NextPart_000_0106_01C7268C.5EC675D0 Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="----=_NextPart_001_0107_01C7268C.5EC675D0" ------=_NextPart_001_0107_01C7268C.5EC675D0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="windows-1250" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Thanks for the quick responses! I think we have the basis for a good, educational discussion and hopefully can carry these forward to a final = set of recommendations. With regard to specific comments:=20 =20 Hamid wrote: I think the importance of good workmanship and proper = component selection has not been emphasized enough. =20 I agree entirely. If you put a $4 Radio Shack toggle switch in to = control a critical system, I think you are playing Russian Roulette. I recall = years ago talking to the shop manager at Lancair Avionics (several shop = managers ago). He had tested many rocker switches, and found most to be not especially reliable. =20 =20 Can some of you contribute suggestions on what constitutes a = satisfactory component (like the diode mentioned) for various applications? Can we compile some suggested work standards for the electrical work in our airplanes? Many standards exist. It would be great if they could be distilled by those who work with these standards every day, and = assembled in one place for all of us to reference. Regarding the question of panel switches, I followed Brent Regan=92s lead and put in high quality, environmentally sealed Honeywell/Microswitch sealed toggle switches. = (Eaton makes a similar line.) These are qualified for use in tanks, Humvees = and other vehicles operating in awful environments. Not cheap, but since switches represent potential single point failures, I believe their selection is wise.=20 =20 Hamid also wrote: Looking over your design, I see one issue: Will the = bus 1 to bus 2 diode keep you from reliably getting the low voltage warning on = bus 2? Beats me, Hamid, I am just a dumb mechanical engineer. What do your = think, and what would you recommend? =20 Also, to all reviewing my dodgy sketch, you missed that I forgot to = insert the second diode to feed the avionics bus. See the missing diode now? = (My sketching workmanship standards need improvement.) =20 =20 John wrote: If one uses the B&C voltage regulators and the circuit = therein to power a caution lamp, it would be adequate to detect a pending low voltage on a buss. No? I'm not sure how the Chelton gauges are wired, = but they should provide voltage readouts from the two busses, and probably current as well. =20 Sounds right to me, John, but I am not specifically familiar with the B = and C hardware and not qualified to evaluate it. I can tell you what I have done. Based on recommendations received, when I upgraded my early generation (circa 1999) Chelton hardware I tossed the EAU (engine = monitoring unit) and purchased an Electronics International MVP-50. Among many = other things, I have it configured to monitor electrical load on both the A = and B buss (amperes being drawn by the aircraft in each system) and voltage = levels on each buss. The unit permits one to set trip levels for alarm, and = the alarm is both audible and visible. As long as the cross feed is not engaged, failure of one alternator should result in low bus voltage and = an alarm. But because I have one little alternator and one big one, the subsequent response strategy and load shedding depends on which = alternator continues to operate. Once I understand the fault and shed load, I will head for the ground. Note that Columbia (and probably Cirrus) have two = big alternators. =20 =20 John also wrote: One philosophical slant for me is the use of the = essential and avionics busses. They complicate the design and increase the parts count, with their consequent effect on reliability. With a reliable crossfeed contactor, you can have the same benefits of both of these = busses. The only thing for the pilot would be to manually reduce the electrical = load as required. =20 I understand your point, but suggest you consider the following: What = about the case of a cross feed contactor (or its switch or its wiring to and = from the switch or contactor attachments points=85.) failing? A single point failure and poof- benefits evaporate. Would you test the cross feed = system at each run up to make sure it works? Even if it does, a subsequent = single point failure in the cross feed hardware, and you have a problem. = Consider also a bad short on one buss that takes it off line. If you hit the = cross feed as your first response you might bring down the second buss as it = leaps into the short circuit. Now the airplane is dark and everything turns = off. Oops. Consider this and other possible failure modes. A complete = =93failure modes and effects analysis=94 (FMEA) considers literally hundreds of combinations and permutations of this type. Today it is done for FAR 23 certification. Most of us are not capable of doing such a thorough job. = So we should steal good designs from others if we are confident that they = are =93better.=94 =20 =20 Scott (and via Scott, Klaus) wrote lots of good stuff including:=20 =20 * It was reported on the Lancair Mail List that Light Speed Engineering is no longer shipping/selling dual ignition systems and only recommends a single system with a mag backup because of too many experimental aircraft's unreliable electrical systems. To which Klaus replied: There was a concern for a while when we had a few sensor = failures on the Continentals used on Lancairs. The engine builder would set up = the proper clearance per our instructions, test run the engine and deliver = it. The proud owner would then install his own baffling between the case and = our mounting bracket. This would reduce the clearance to the point that the sensors could get damaged. I made an assumption as to the cause of the caution (faulty electrical systems). I have to remind myself how to spell ASS-U-ME. :-( I am = pleased that the problem has been isolated and corrected. Apparently my = Continental engine was caught in this cautionary period, and the engine builder put = on one mag and one Lightspeed ignition system. Now my engine is making its = way across the Pacific this way. Alas.=20 =20 * Elder* Cessna aircraft (I have some experience) use crappy components and connectors and are frequently full of architecture and = design shortcuts used to save MONEY, not lives.=20 Absolutely correct, in my direct experience. I could not believe the = crap that Cessna put in my brand new TR-182 when I bought it new in 1979. = That includes switches, circuit breakers, and other important electrical components. =20 * Sorry, I cannot trust that the FAA knows any better than an experimental aircraft builder that actually built his/her airplane and studied available information on how-to-do-it. Ah, Scott, you are being cynical, but your cynicism is not misplaced. I agree that a builder familiar with the topic should be able to build an electrical system equal to or better than that specified by the FAA. = But I am a little familiar with some current certification processes via the = CAA (Australia=92s equivalent to the FAA). CAA follows FAA on FAR 23, and = in my recent discussions with CAA I learned about requirements that = manufacturers present a quantitative safety case that subjects system designs to = thorough data validation and mathematical analysis. This is a post =93elder = Cessna=94 phenomenon, and probably more than we as homebuilders can hope to = achieve. =20 =20 I merely suggest that FAA-approved designs for MODERN aircraft provide a good STARTING point. If you are limiting yourself to day VFR, your standards can (should) be relaxed. But since some of us are apparently flying night, IFR, single pilot, over the mountains at high altitude, I suggest we get the best input we can obtain. Hence my call for an = exchange of thoughts and preparation of some recommendations and example = workmanship standards that can be used by all to improve the quality of our = projects.=20 =20 * One of the things the builder cannot fix with hardware is the loss of life from serious lapses of judgment, training and knowledge in the = other single-point failure, the pilot. Excellent point. We should ever lose sight of the fact that most of the = time pilots kill pilots, not airplanes.=20 =20 Let the adventure continue! =20 Fred Moreno AKA Captain Tuna, Chicken of the Skies --=20 No virus found in this outgoing message. Checked by AVG Free Edition. Version: 7.1.409 / Virus Database: 268.15.26/598 - Release Date: = 22/12/2006 =20 =20 ------=_NextPart_001_0107_01C7268C.5EC675D0 Content-Type: text/html; charset="windows-1250" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

Thanks for the quick responses!  I think = we have the basis for a good, educational discussion and hopefully can carry = these forward to a final set of recommendations.  With regard to specific comments:

 

Hamid wrote: I think the importance of = good workmanship and proper component selection has not been emphasized = enough.

 

I agree entirely.  If you put a $4 Radio Shack = toggle switch in to control a critical system, I think you are playing Russian = Roulette.  I recall years ago talking to the shop manager at Lancair = Avionics (several shop managers = ago).  He had tested many rocker switches, and = found most to be not especially reliable. 

 

Can some of you contribute suggestions on what = constitutes a satisfactory component (like the diode mentioned) for various = applications?  Can we compile some suggested work standards for the electrical work in = our airplanes?  Many standards exist.  = It would be great if they could be distilled by those who work with these standards = every day, and assembled in one place for all of us to reference. Regarding = the question of panel switches, I followed Brent Regan=92s lead and put in high quality, environmentally sealed Honeywell/Microswitch sealed toggle = switches.  (Eaton makes a similar line.)  These are qualified for use in tanks, = Humvees and other vehicles operating in awful environments.  Not cheap, but = since switches represent potential single point failures, I believe their = selection is wise.

 

Hamid also wrote: Looking over your design, = I see one issue: Will the bus 1 to bus 2 diode keep you from reliably getting = the low voltage warning on bus 2?

Beats me, Hamid, I am just a dumb mechanical = engineer.  What do your think, and what would you recommend?

 

Also, to all reviewing my dodgy sketch, you missed that I forgot = to insert the second diode to feed the avionics bus.  See the missing = diode now?  (My sketching workmanship standards need = improvement.)

 

 

John wrote: If one uses the B&C = voltage regulators and the circuit therein to power a caution lamp, it would be adequate to detect a pending low voltage on a buss. No? I'm not sure how = the Chelton gauges are wired, but they should provide voltage readouts from = the two busses, and probably current as well.

 

Sounds right to me, John, but I am not specifically = familiar with the B and C hardware and not qualified to evaluate it.  I can = tell you what I have done.  Based on recommendations received, when I = upgraded my early generation (circa 1999) Chelton hardware I tossed the EAU = (engine monitoring unit) and purchased an Electronics International = MVP-50.  Among many other things, I have it = configured to monitor electrical load on both the A and B buss (amperes being drawn = by the aircraft in each system) and voltage levels on each buss.  The unit permits one to set trip levels for alarm, and the alarm is both audible = and visible.  As long as the cross feed is not engaged, failure of one alternator should result in low bus voltage and an alarm.  But = because I have one little alternator and one big one, the subsequent response = strategy and load shedding depends on which alternator continues to = operate.  Once I understand the fault and shed load, I will head for the ground. =  Note that Columbia (and probably Cirrus) = have two big alternators. 

 

John also wrote: One philosophical slant for = me is the use of the essential and avionics busses. They complicate the design = and increase the parts count, with their consequent effect on reliability. = With a reliable crossfeed contactor, you can have the same benefits of both of = these busses. The only thing for the pilot would be to manually reduce the = electrical load as required.

 

I understand your point, but suggest you consider the following: What about the case of a cross feed contactor (or its switch = or its wiring to and from the switch or contactor attachments points=85.) failing?  A single point failure and poof- benefits = evaporate.  Would you test the cross feed system at each run up to make sure it = works?  Even if it does, a subsequent single point failure in the cross feed = hardware, and you have a problem.  Consider also a bad short on one buss that = takes it off line.  If you hit the cross feed as your first response you = might bring down the second buss as it leaps into the short circuit.  Now = the airplane is dark and everything turns off.  Oops.  Consider = this and other possible failure modes.  A complete =93failure modes and = effects analysis=94 (FMEA) considers literally hundreds of combinations and permutations of this type.  Today it is done for FAR 23 certification.  Most of us are not capable of doing such a thorough job.  So we should steal good designs from others if we are = confident that they are =93better.=94 

 

Scott (and via Scott, Klaus) wrote lots of good stuff including:

 

  • It = was reported on the Lancair = Mail List that Light Speed Engineering is no longer = shipping/selling dual ignition systems and only recommends a single system with a = mag backup because of too many experimental aircraft's unreliable electrical = systems.  To = which Klaus replied: There was a concern = for a while when we had a few sensor failures on the Continentals used on Lancairs. The engine builder would set up the proper clearance per = our instructions, test run the engine and deliver it. The proud owner = would then install his own baffling between the case and our mounting = bracket. This would reduce the clearance to the point that the sensors could = get damaged.

I made an = assumption as to the cause of the caution (faulty electrical systems).  I have to = remind myself how to spell ASS-U-ME.  L  I am pleased that the problem has been isolated and corrected.  = Apparently my Continental engine was caught in this cautionary period, and the = engine builder put on one mag and one Lightspeed ignition system.  Now my = engine is making its way across the Pacific this way.  Alas.

 

  • Elder* = Cessna aircraft (I have some experience) use crappy components and = connectors and are frequently full of architecture and design shortcuts used = to save MONEY, not lives.

Absolutely = correct, in my direct experience.  I could not believe the crap that Cessna put = in my brand new TR-182 when I bought it new in 1979.  That includes = switches, circuit breakers, and other important electrical = components.

 

  • Sorry, I = cannot trust that the FAA knows any better than an experimental aircraft builder that actually built his/her = airplane and studied available information on = how-to-do-it.

Ah, Scott, you = are being cynical, but your cynicism is not misplaced.  I agree that a = builder familiar with the topic should be able to build an electrical system equal to or = better than that specified by the FAA.  But I am a little familiar with = some current certification processes via the CAA (Australia=92s equivalent to the FAA).  CAA follows FAA on FAR 23, and in my = recent discussions with CAA I learned about requirements that manufacturers = present a quantitative safety case that subjects system designs to thorough data = validation and mathematical analysis.  This is a post =93elder Cessna=94 = phenomenon, and probably more than we as homebuilders can hope to achieve.  =

 

I merely = suggest that FAA-approved designs for MODERN aircraft provide a good STARTING point.  If you = are limiting yourself to day VFR, your standards can (should) be = relaxed.  But since some of us are apparently flying night, IFR, single pilot, over = the mountains at high altitude, I suggest we get the best input we can obtain.  Hence my call for an exchange of thoughts and preparation = of some recommendations and example workmanship standards that can be used by = all to improve the quality of our projects.

 

  • One of the = things the builder cannot fix with hardware is the loss of life from = serious lapses of judgment, training and knowledge in the other single-point failure, the pilot.

Excellent point. We should ever lose sight of the = fact that most of the time pilots kill pilots, not airplanes.

 

Let the adventure continue!

 

Fred Moreno

AKA Captain Tuna, Chicken of the = Skies


--
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Free Edition.
Version: 7.1.409 / Virus Database: 268.15.26/598 - Release Date: = 22/12/2006

------=_NextPart_001_0107_01C7268C.5EC675D0-- ------=_NextPart_000_0106_01C7268C.5EC675D0 Content-Type: image/jpeg; name="image001.jpg" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-ID: /9j/4AAQSkZJRgABAQEAYABgAAD//gAcU29mdHdhcmU6IE1pY3Jvc29mdCBPZmZpY2X/2wBDAAoH BwgHBgoICAgLCgoLDhgQDg0NDh0VFhEYIx8lJCIfIiEmKzcvJik0KSEiMEExNDk7Pj4+JS5ESUM8 SDc9Pjv/wAALCAF9AUMBAREA/8QAGwAAAgMBAQEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAECBAUDBgf/xABBEAABAwMD AgMHAQcBBgYDAAABAAIDBAUREiExBkETUWEUFSIycYGRQiMzUmJygqGSFjRDRFNUJDZjscHRVaLx /90ABAAo/9oACAEBAAA/APsCOw9VVrK+KhcPEY5wPkMqNNc4Kp+mPLD5OC43qJz6Zk0YOqA6sBXa adtRTxytIOsf5XXCEJb743GFkz1k7OoY6YEGF8eSPVarwCeeFWudeLbQSVZjMmj9IRQVjbjQR1TG GMPGSHdlknqLxb/FQ0zdUJyHu9VavlbPA2KkpCPaKh2GnyHmla6ypNTJb6uRskkY+dq1chrMk4A5 JXCuq46OifUPOWgbY7qM9yp4KNlXLs14GAeSuVwpKe4QxyySuhLNw4cBFTVvobf4zHCUtA+InkLM r7jUVkkXskuhoaHu9VuU0njU8T38kbrsgg7+RWL1JUmOgZSs3kqHBuBzhatHCKWiggaNmMA+67HV pwAAg4AGc/ZPbtwhCEIQPVCEL//Q+wYQlkE4OcpOaHj4mtyO5CiI26shjdXmApOGWlsjQWnb6rKa 59pqTG8F1I85af4SVrscHtDmnLTwUigpA4afqvP19ZDb+pTNUOwwQ/D6qjX3Kukkhr3OdBTGTS0d yrckk3UM8cTGPioozl2eXq1fah9vtsdNSgNMzhGwDssaGGsorpRk0WNGQ5/8RXeU19d1C4xUzm+C whrncZVi1VDLZLLHWU72VLj8/IKlcK2S8V7LbTFzGEZlPGyqV0kkFA20SRve7xBodzlq0LxTvDqJ wYXwx41MC63uKurKKFlI0AOPx+gVabpp8tudE6qeZSNt9h6JV9kqH0UAppA2SGPS7+ZXenzMbfon OXMdjK1FznnipYjLM/SwDclecpmVF1rpLxOwiCAEQM8x5r0lNOypp2TN7jceRXVIoHKaEipD5UkI 52Rxsv/R+wKSikeVGUlsTnAZLRnCzI7xUSh2mgk1NOFbppK6R+ZIWMb9V3ljZMx0crctPmsovq7O /Dsy0ruDyWrRp62nqo9ccrXeYzuu3bOCQgt+IYz9FVqrbS1dQ2aena97eC5TqKSnqmNjmga5jDlo PAK7RxsjbhjcAeSp3C3Q3EReJlroXh7XZVt0bHuBc3JZ8pKYAwTtk8lRcxsuDIxriOMqLKWFkxmb G0SEYJA3Km+Jkjw97AXDgkKRGXZyEZAORyouezhz2tPqVSuN0p6SB7TI0yEfCA5VLZcKKkoQZ6hj ZHnURncKM/VMGdFFTyVLzsCBsuTrfcr0We8nCGmBz4be/wBVvxxMhhELGYjDdIHbC4Q0Jp5C6N5D CfkHCtZQknlGUBM8ICEL/9L7AUHhGUKJ5T7JDY7bfRRlljjbrle1gHmVRdeoTMyKCN0uo4LgNgrx Ac1zXDY+fks2ey0p3Y8wau4K5C0VejEVxfp80Ott1a0GO4Yx/EEzFfYwMSxP8lDVfwCHeEAO+E2G /BuoGJwPGFCeqvkMTnSRxaQOVRtl1v1wkmMfhFrNhsr/AInUQGCyH8JAdSP7wD7JOpOonAl1XDH9 AhlqvL8mS64+gT9zXTGPex/CRstWRme6P08ZAwpjpiM/vqyaT7qJ6RoHSiSR8j9O+C5XIrDa4iXe ztPbL1ejp6eAZhhY0eTQpSl3hPLfm05C42+oNTSh7t3AkO3VgDASQmjCMJoQNkL/0/sOEkHcIRlI 8o7JKhU2eGrqhNNK8tH6c7K3FBFCzTExrW+WFJxLWlztw1ZTS661xLtTYI+GjkrVDWxAM04aBuVn wVVTWVjvCa1sEZxk91pd8kDJ49FmXSd7y2lhOXyckdldpac01MyFpJ09yqN/n8C1S45dwqHRrHtt 8r3DLZH7HzW7UTtpmhxGdRwF2acgHJH2Se4BrnHfSM7qrbqp9XC6QsDQHYG3Kt7+n4WbeMltOxpL Q5+StJvAA7J481n3pz/dziHYAeNx5K7BjwGHOcgY9V0/Vk9h+VTgpHU9Q97Hfs37lvqrWUITCeUZ QhGV/9T7BlG2OUsb8p5QoqQ4QeFFMpDhBOBuMoY0MHwsaAfJBGdjvlc44WU5IYMBxz910yc7dlxF NEyo8doy8+fZd+y851i90dqDhxqwtHp+BsFnp2t7t1K5UUzahjMuxpdldm8KD2a43NzjIwuNDT+y 0/hZzvlWVyngZOxuobjcKY2aPNGQBnUMjzK4TVVEYyyaaLSeQSutOY/Cb4TtcePhcp9t0wkOU0kI QmEzwv/V+vIQhCkopoSRgkgLHuV8qKCqEYoHSR7fGOM+SkLncnnItjgDxuma+66sNtox/Uj2665z 7u//AGT9surhvQNH1cg1V1PFDHn+pL2m75/3KP8A1pGe+OzppYm54y5ULrQ3u60rKaWGAN1ZJBVu KO9wQtjibTtY0Bo3XR3v3TsKdLR1B/FCk6O/loHiQA54TMF+JGZ4G7dgj2a+Yx7XFn6J+y3h2M1s Yx/KmaG6nm4tH0aqc/TtbVnE92m8M8huynB01R0NDMJHGofpJaXncLv0y9xsjMuzhxH+Vr5yBvlC E+2+clAG25BPojjflHDcu2VWS40UWddZE0f1cLgL5bnP0tqdR/kC/9b67FIyeMPjcHA9wVIYLd9l xq6yCipvHneAwHH1Wfbb37yr5YI4tMLBkOPJWrqYXFmckYyAs6qu7YKoQRxGRoOJJBw0q86oYw6T IwEea6YQkhG+Qc7hZXUD8U0TSd3SbLTiJ8Np/lHKkRqOShGW+p+yCN8EY8kaQkWlxB1EYTxkg77J 9iEsepQA0kgchADSRtv5o07nOxCeBnKPuUYGEhhrsjKoXevjoKKR8gBdpIAPdeEtfUFdTFkcTmth Mm4P1Xv2XWgcwH2qMOxuM90/elD/ANyz7FRdd6Jv/Fz9AvOXG+3CirTJTSCaB/8AL8qtUvVUmge1 0xz2czutFnUVuziWUxHGQHBW6WvprjETBLrbnC8xe7NRsrqOjpISZJpNUjnHOAv/1/ol2hhttq/8 JDHHJIQzIbwqVFB7prqaCKtfUyTbvaHbBemke2Nrnv2YwZJ815OskqOoJpJ2RE0NPuB/GQrVjL6a jqa98WkYwxnknFXSUdudVSanVNS7EYPbKVsp3io0V73CQnUGgbOKz6jxTUSGR72u1HIxwvapFCWQ jIBwsa+N8esoIG75kyQFs7A6RwNkLnLPDTtMs8jY2ebjhZh6lt5qWQseX63Y1N4WvjBIznyQdjgp gHCXYnyR2z2R5eqYGrY8nlVqSviqppoGbOhOCrG+N90boT7KJXm+rqSqrKfVEcNYN1h9OdNSV0Uc 0zCIs5yeCvYtsVuj4pwSurbZRg5FMwfZdW0lO3iFn4WTf6WpqY46WipW6XHLn6cYSj6flngbHVVO A0AaWNVxvT9uaQHw+Jju7dXYKaGli8OCNsbc8AL/0PqM9CPePvFuXvYzS1i7PgbW0pZUR6S8bg9l woLNR0EhfG0l+fndufsrr2h7Cx41NcDkFQhgip4xFHGGsAwQOCmyGNkZjawaDy0pPp4ZCwyRA+H8 m3CmYmOkD3NBd2Pkk6mgkcXvjaXHk4Ui8D5i0fdc3VELTvIz8qArYAd5mD7pGupv+4Z+VXq75QUc bnyygkDZrV4+q6sqqu7QzQQAMY4NaP8A5Xvo3F8THuGC5oJUl4zqSCeq6ipaeeQGkPxua09lft9A y5V5qfCZFR07sRNby7HdekzvluBgd/JGoPHwuDvUIJw0knAHJWZN1DbaapEJlJJ5IGQEVN/oacgB xn1ceGM4Vyjq4a2IPidk92nkLs7DWkk4AOc+ixrEfGrq6rAwx8mB6raxj8oQg8JD5ln334bRU4+b Sp2SIQ2ama3uzKvIQnhLhGcr/9H68hCEIQg8JhCxTYpXn9pcHuHpsmOnKXGXyTPPnqUx05QEfLL/ AKlIdPW0cxyH+5ZN96dLmRuoYWjB+LUVU6c6bc+c1FSW6I3cDzXtOMafl4CQOCQey87QMF1vdZVy jMUbfCYP/pQraJtqEUVFVze0SP8A2cerYeav3isqIKWnpIsGqqPgLhwM8lZstfPY6Rlugm9quEr9 znOAvQlk8lAWO/fOjxkcZWLboIZbTUUjYGCpZnXqG59VbsUdBHTtYxsbZhkOD+Vpx00UEj3xsDS7 nA5VG/VZpLWdHzSHw2/dWLZSikt8UWNyMu9SraSEik7grN6idi0TYOCcBW7c0ttlO3yYFZ7lCE8p L//S+vIQn2S7oRnySJOd9kwfPCZBG+QjI/h/ygOOOcpfVCeR5Knc5xBQzvIGdOG+pStEHgW2EHlw 1H7q6Ml2efJcqkPNNMGD4sbLy1DcK+0sjpRbnuLyXOfjkrZtlBIJjXVnx1D92g/oCV1tMtfPA+CX w3RE7/XlVZrCYZ4Kqlb4k8Z+MuPzLvX3K4xtZBBTap5NtYOzFKht/u2OWrqXmapI3I7+mFn+x110 r46tsLadjT8w2JXp2uIDWc7brIvcEs1TRtZHriY/U4LX/wAJIQghRJWJ1VUMgtoD3AFzxt3Viz3m jr2ezwl2uNgGCOVqDYkd09xzsjODg/4Rnyyv/9P696d0cdikXNby5oHmSoOqqdpwZmj7qLq6lYPi nZ+VXdeaBp/fg/RczfqEbNc530aoyXgu/cUszvq3Ch7ZdJdo6Ij1cVJtPeH7ukjZ6Zyn7rrpP3tb p+gUvcx71kufqtJNCSxep3EUEbQeZAPqtanc0wRtBGzQF035CW+CSeTwk52wBAw3ck9lGKeGZzvB e1+OQ05wugOAWjdMAjYYxjlJ2wyQBjjHKiACM4GTyUyAcDjHkn8Q2yMJDJaQRlPjAQN00kYyFE43 /wAfVfN+rpqma7CN7nHDhpaO61bXSXuOX26GjazLQ3SVu+NftOBTxD1ypxvvmPijgz9UGK9l+rxY QPIL/9T6Z4N3f81RG36NQ2guBOXVw+wTdap3/vLhIR5NUPcUXD6qZ4+qfuCiz8Qe76uUxY6Bv/Bz 9XKxHbqOL5admfPC6thhbs2Fjfsug2HA+yQz659U8b5PKD6YRhLGd0ZyjOEYxusPqKNlRJS0z36I yclyuUclFRRiFs4djkuO6sCtpW/8Vm6Rr6X/AKzF5Tq7qR8TmUdve1znD4iq3TL5KO4RyOmc8StJ ewb4Xqxd2OdhsEhx5DlP3s4cUsp+yBc5XcUUv3SdcqjP+4SFHvCsdsKB33Um1lw7UA/KXtVzPy0s Y+pQZrtjU6GID03XOCa51TNTTG1ucEYXT2e5u/5ljfso+w3D/vU20dyb8tW0/VRxeIwTqikA7LOr LbcLjcqSV9MyJsTsveO69IGgN0j4QE8oX//V+vIQhCEIQpIQeFFSQkUk1XqaKnrHNdPFqLeM9lD3 dRA/uG59Qn7DSjiFv4R7FT/9Fn4Xgrva6mo6pkZBDs75MDbC9bYrEy2x+LNh0zhj6ei2gwYGzQB2 wlxwnkoSQnnKWD2OEmxhgw0YHkFJBSHKCMFHbHZB35Rwv//W+vIQhCEIQhPKMoCeEsppHlJCZ9SS kCg7hROyzH5d1LEdstjzsFrA5J2SYc8jBHdMjKSeNku6E8Ix6owkN0yk0bpkbpJjdf/X+vZT7JDd MjBQRhCMFGEIRhGEYRhNJNI8pITKQQkQVmNIPUpPdsW48lqNJbyNypbAIyop9ku6FLKMhLISHKAm Nih3KS//0Pr44Ue6l2SbsUzygoBwU9SEigJ5RlGUIyEkso5QhCROCjKMrNpm6r/O886Fp90+ySEI QhPGUYwkhCF//9H68hA+ZM8pIQhCZKQOUIQhMJDlNLI8kcoQhI8oACRWXFJ4XUMjTxIzZa3OCmkh CEJlLcFPskhC/9L68hCEIQhMcpd0IQhCEwkfRCe3kjKCdkDdI7FB5SUSVlyfH1NA0fpi1ErXHCEI QhCBgd0HcppIX//T+vIQhHbKBwhCExykeUIQmdgkhCY2SynhHCXITCDjCgM90AggkHhIrIgdnqyY fwRLaA2QjhCEIRj1RwhGV//U+vIQhCfbCQ4ITwfJGEkwkUcfZAIPCOQny3ZHHKSeEHblJG6Odkcb IQk7sFVmrqWCoEEsjWSOGcEpmuow4Dx4/wDUsmjqYB1DVzyVDAwtDQcrTku1FE0E1TM+S5+/7b4j WeONbzgALRZkDjV33QhCEIQeF//V+upoQhCP1f8A2qgutv8AFdE6qhbI3kZ3XX22kxn2qLH9SDUQ O3EzMf1INZSjmojH1cuZuNIOamIfdcpL7bYj8dS0/RcndSW1gz4+c+QXF3VVt4D5XEeTVE9U05OI qad39qR6inO0VqmfnzSderu44htLvuUzV9QSHIoo2/1FI/7SOO4haEexdQv39rjb6YT9hv8A/wB+ 1b2UkISyjIzudwsS9dNw3eQ1BleycNwzBws20W231fiUtXG9tXDsRq+Yea0nWC1QQmSWNwZyXOcs rwIrhL7PaqLLAcGZ4yFsW/pqko3CWZvjzDfU7hv0WyRtumUghCDknZBz32X/1vrwc12wO6QHGdsJ oQhLKhM90cLpGtLi0LL/ANn7VWyGsfTgmUb+hTd0ran7eHI0ejlAdLW0bATf6029K2wcskP1cure m7Uw5FOSfMnK7NstubxSMP2XRtso28UsQx/KuraSmbxTxj+1TEUbfljaPoFLA8ggbcIQnnCWB5IQ hCMKMhDYy48N3KypeoaFtPJJHUMe6Plh5Xlrh1IKuWGtpqYwVEZ3I/UFzquo6q8OAbA8MHLB3V2C 53dsQbS05jA/SGr1tsmqJqKN9UwskI3arZOUiUcIQkQdJ0nBwv/X9ZdOqK0+NTRQiMsdjUe649Oy 3KS6skmndIzBy3svcuALj6BJCEJJHgjz2KpWqTIqIDuIpDhX9hwEE4B33HbCMgjflLvg5+ylxnGd kj6lGMdwU8HOCEt0b+i5ieN07oA4axvhdCduN/JR8WMu0h4LvLO6khCEIUXtLgW7YOxBWTN0xapZ C/2fBdzg8qYsVsp4i4QBwYNweyp9N0MLm1FUGDS92GjHC32sYGnQ0D7KW3GSccIUTnKkAcJ4Rhf/ 0PqVdc4KMYf8Uh4aOViSWOa8OM0+IQTsO5C2bbaqa3/u2nUBjJ7q+fhyO5S7ZTwUshB25SSyMjdZ lrJF2r4/JwWtjn0WTcb9FR1UFOzEkkhwQOQtNzw2EvO405wqsdyhNC2pedLNWPqpz18NO2N2XF0v DfNd3yNYwuds3HdZ1Pe6WoqTAWFhzgE91oSSMjYZJH6WN7qpXVrorcammxJhEdwjFuirZRp1txpP crhWSxQTQ1cYIkm2DVqai6Nv83KxKSiMlfNP4pEjHbDstzshCEISPKR4VW5SsgoJnvdp+FeesHUc TZGULmadTjhy9aCMAFwPlhLGN8oygl3cgJa2NBL3jH1VC43qitcQkkeHZ7Ar/9H3DOqRdpW01tic 2Q9ytOiszY3+PVP8Sb14Wl+PsoyPZHG573YaBysuDqK3y1Apmu+In5itIVcB+ESM/KHVUIG8rB90 nVdMwjMzN/IpGqp8ZMzcfVc5LpRMzqqo9uyxrn1bTQxOZT/G/sQNl5+jv9w9onfEwZlkALu69jWX D2S2s1b1MjNm+q8uyJsNUx0gkdVCTIyOy9WamSehk+AgBh5Cx7fDNcWRwkFtOw5P1Vylb7TeZMtI ZBs3KlcJXT3RtO+URQxfET5rlUMhnmjioodw7eRSrPEudebewuZFE34z5lcIIKupDbeGOZBE/DnH uFdqqJ9TX09OPhp4RnHmp3GkndPDPTMDvD2APCg+vuMB/b02ryLV2tUc8niVEzdGt2zVooQhCEJE Z2CxuqaWertEjICdTeQO68p05aKi4vz4oY+HZ3ovVi1XFgAZW7DzKmKK7N/5ppSNHdT/AM20INuu T/3lXt/KUCzOwfGqpHA/zL//0vb3vpVtTEx1O5z3N7ErpYrHPSVQnfGI9LdgvR9ksYVS6U8tVb5I YfnPCxLd0kxoD6kFj+fhK1G2Kjac4dn+pT9x0TuWuP8Acl7hoc50O/1KXuikAxocR6lcXWCgeSTG 7PbdYVV03PHJIImNEWkuyVLpGyRmnNXOdRL9mlbTbXJJeTWTu1Rt+Rp4Cs1NEJq2OYNA0c7cq44A jGBjGMKMcbIhiNgYPIBAjY0khgBPJA5VeptlNVSeJKwly6xU8cDQ1jA0BTbG0SF4aNR5ONyug247 pEAnONwjtjshH/whCE0gclCMpbn0SPGMZB5XnLTC6g6nrYG/JP8AHxwvTZGdhwkc9iB9kD1wUYHl hf/T+u6UEd8/hSA8ySllHKNIO26O+5J2wjnsEcDgJZ34CMn0/CWSG42/Cr15It1QRz4ZXGxxMitE DWjctySr+DtvuE87eW6RySThAGfNBBA43SH1KltlIkjkYSMjG8vaPuoGqhaMumjH9y5G50TeaqP/ AFKJvFvHNVH+VE3q2j/m2flP3xb/APu4/wAq7lCCdlEHdSLgOSkUDlIrFHw9XDPeL8rdOCcjukhf /9T68hBTCjhMJg7pFCFHunlPCzbvXw0cLopWOIlaQXAbBZVN1I2npo6aOjleGDAOOV3F/rX7xWt5 Hqh16uedrW9S983Qj4bU/wCqTbrey7a2n7oFb1BI7V7E1n1Q6TqKT9EbVFtN1DIcOqI2D0UjaLrK f21xLR5NSZ0zIXZmuMzvoujOlqX9c8rvqV0b0vbhywu+pUx0zaxv4P8AlI9M2s/8H/KP9mbV/wBA /laqf6VHskg/LupdkDlIrFf/AOaYnf8Aprc7BC//1fryEIQhPGUYwkhH6lEb5TwmovijlGJGtcBv ghQEEYILI2j7KY8tOPoEY+qfHfH1Rz3ynhLCCD2RtjflCaEHhJNJPsolJI78pg7J5RlY0v8A5piH lGtsdl//1vrx5QhCEITQkhCMIQhB4SG3CEwgpJoPKQ5TwhCEYQkjPZRJQEkJZ3TWPcHCK/0Mndzc Ff/X+vDsc7IO5QhCEIQhCEIQhCEYRhCEYQjCMIQhCE9KikeUkFLCY4Swkv/Q+g3cA3OhcTgh2Ft9 sdkxscJoyhCEZQhCEITwlwmkjKMhGQjKMoQhCEJpKWVBGMpEYCSCcHCZSX//0frJWJU5qupII/hL YW5dgrf42xhA5TSTHCEJJjhCEIQeEDKOd0HhH6UkEJDZMblSwkhCEITHKRQg4SOfNJNLIPZHK//S +uOLQ3f/AAs+8VvsFtlnb8+MAFfN2XOsirX1HiSB5OdQPK+o2+V1Rb6eZ/zPYCVZPG2EyQ0cZ+6W Qf0/5QM9kEH/APiB9CgjIwE9J7A8KBkYzGtwbjzKPFi5ErfyoSVMMTPEfKwD+pVmXu3OcQKphPCs wVMNUCYJGvDecFdsoSQeFHHqpIQmkhBTCSExykVJRGyaWMpAZR9l/9P6zNPHBHrkc1rc8krGqOo3 UtU+KS3zOY35ZGDIcFlX68xXS3eDFTztfn+Beeax8whigpJXsYcvOndevi6jqYoY4obNUOa0AA4X U3u6u/dWd+T/ABFJtd1G85FAxg9SujndRv2DIW/dJtN1C75542nyXQ2+9PbiSta0ebRuo+57kebo 4fZIWi5MORdXu+ylHarmXYfcXYypHp5j5NU1ZK8ntlSPT1ORgTzD+5Rd01RvAD5JXY83LncbNQQW ufw6ca2MyHd116Yp4orXC9rSHvGXHzWx9QRuhCMoyO6CjI80icdwmCCjfyRnzSz57Jg+SMhGRnZA Ki54HY/hTyfJJCYSBwV//9T66s6/Qiazzg52GRjsrFB8Vup3Zzlg5Xbw2ciJufUJsYxoOljW55w3 lTYcDfH4QD5kY9EnfFtlIjdPIz3UsjGx3+iiQ7z/AMJ6vL/2RzuRkpY34CELG6nr/Y7Y9jRl8oxj 0Xhaa81EfhR+1PiaDsPRfRKO60T6WPFZHI7Tvl3dXGzRuGRIw/3BS1DzH5S1NG5c0D1K5uqqUDLq iMD+oLlJdaCMfFVxD+5V39R2qLY1bXH+VV39WW5oy1sj/wClqQ6pgcMtpagj+lI9UZ+W3VB/tSb1 JK47WufHrsojqKuOcWab0yU/f1yPFnk/KBeL075bVj6pmv6gfxb2D6peJ1K/iGJiG0fUUrDrqo4j 5AI923//APJt/C9AhC//1frhTVa4tL7fM3zYVztDi61wejcK6hCEIQhSPCijOyAd0imse/Wptxjz qILGlZ3TFmo5rVrqIWSkPLfiCvy9J2eQ6hTujP8AI5cXdIU2f2dVUMH9SQ6ULdm3Oox9U/8AZQHa S4zvb5Ero3pG3A4kMrx/UurOmrQx21MXfUq0yzW6LGmijx6jK7tpKVnyU8Q/tXUQxgfu2AfRAaB2 H4TwCc6c/ZBzj5Uw5wSJ9cfZA35OSgAgppJpFf/W+uoQVznaHU8gO40nZULFPG+3NbraHBxGknda T3CJj3P4aMrzUHU881S6dsbfYg/Rk85XpQ7U1rxuCMhPY8ggnyT2AJA2I2ys2618lGxkcID6mXYD sFCmmrbfRSTXWZjh20jf6LvQ3alr3FkWWvAzpdyVdyhUrpcW22ASuifJk40tCxoupq0VLDNReFC9 wa3Vycr0TdUmDuG8+qmVzeNbSM7kFZPTJLaepixsyUrbTwMYSOyOUIQgJnflJMBCMBCMdhjCfc7H BS2aBz65Qjjlf//X+vAEjJ2+qR2Gcj8rk+phi+eVo+4VWW9W6AZfUA/TdY926wiZSPZRxPc+QYDi F5Cg94SVMUkcrhK5/APZfSLjN7PZ5nzHdsWD9V5igo4nGh9ocY4HDW7yc5exklbDTOkHxBjcjHCw DfZaO1zTzvDpZifCjHZXenJaqotglq3Zkect9AnWhsN3pqp4/Zj4c+q6X1uuhbJjIDwcdilQULm1 j61+kamgMAGMBaSFxqp4qanfNMAWsGQD3KyaGkkudV7wqo/2bT+yYt4jOk9woEZSwNQHmsTpvInu I3IEq3AckeqllJHKBktz+QngHujG/klnBTys+vvNFbXtZUSYc4ZwPJFFe6CvcG08uS7gHutAZOcd kb75x6IQe23KwLvdpzcYaOifjDhqct1ri9oB3wPi+qlv2AX/0Pfm3X6T5rg1v0CPcl2kGJbqfspD puQjEtxnd6AqTelKHmWaaT+5XILJbqcYbTh3q/dUrp05BcpWPDzDoadmjAVfpi0U1O18zvjljeRv 2U+qJXPfT0LST4zsuA7hVaq6wPpnW6CFsj4wGMPcFb9PTPdamU8xILo8Oxys+l6XpqdsniSmZ5aQ wu/TlXbTQS0EeiSXWM7DyVS83GGaT3ZBiScvBOn9CndKxsNM23ta6SocAMALQpY3Mpow/wCZrRn0 XZCw+oqWvqzCyki1sacu3XOCPqWFo+CBzBwzyC0qWtqXyBlVSmMjlzeFeyFwq6qGkhMszg0DjzXi rZ1CaWqn8PBjlm3zyvax11K9jXePGMj+JSNTTjmZn+oI9qp8Z8eP/UFE1tLgj2hgONt15rqS41VH WRVlFUh0ZbpcwefmrdFebg1gdU0/isxkvZ2WtQ3KmuLS6nfnT8wPIVvY7hC8beqUx3eYSN8aSpIb GOdIW7S2mktlCwmNodG3Vq7/AEVNt+rKund7JT+G4ZOp/cBa9rqnVdFHLKBqJwSFb74WZd7oymZ7 LDl9TKPhaOw81gwxVzbjEx9Ppk5y7utmprZTVxUjZAxzTmQjsv/R+hy9TU0crmNbqDTjPmttCDwk gqPY/RZVgOfah/6hWlLSwzVEc0jAXM4VWls1DRVEk8LP2jzq+JaAI33yg4wkqsVspYKl9SxnxyHJ J7Kx4MTnCTSHOB5I3TzkkpoRskc+aHEah8P3SWL1DRTVcbfDyQBwF5zpuwRV9VVCoBxE7cL0/wDs vbm4wJM/1Jt6Zt4HxeIf7lJnTltHMbifVy7MslAziAbeqhWWiknopYBEAXDY44KxKa2XyuhFJM9t LDEcEj9QXoLZZ6a1tIgJL3ck9yrxJLRnGfRJYlupC+9VNTUsJfn4M8BbMrGysdG7h4I+iwhYKlzh DJU4haeG91vQQCCBsUeAxil+rKquoIHVgq3MBla3AJTfSCWqZUk/E1uNK//S+q+76d03j+H+0dyS oe6qMbeytPqriEISKgdWCAM7FZlgglihndNG5jnSnY91q/MeOPVByedKME+RTAPkPyjB22G3O6iC c7H/AAg6s7p5wEtbGjBdv9UjJGP1gfUpeKznxG/lDZGEE+K3fjdPxQf1t/KYcHbAj65QSBuSMfVY PTJDq654HEv5XoUIQmlgflNJCMDOcblGAgjZJNB32O6//9P68j0QjKMoG5QThIlUrjSPrqYxx1Do HA5DmlZoo7pTStiF1a8uHwhwXUU1/jP+9RHPAIVenqb/ACzyQfsfFj5a7bP0Vh0nUIAPgxI19QEA iOIJBt+fqOqNueFSus15t1A6qmqmFrSMhoXakorhX0jJ2XI6XgEDChDa5pqqWF9xl1MOMeaUFqL6 qZktbIwRcFzsZXCtp6Gla3Xc3PLnYID+FM09mY3e6OIPk5U6l9rjlj8Ktme39RBOyJaq16cRS1rv I4O640c58Asc6sL89gioqIsxRunrInyOADn7NXq7Xbqa2sdJDNrE2CXE7ErS257YzlPCCkhCEIyh CEYQv//U+vIRlCSEZUSUErhPUMp2Fz86TsTjhVLnNQMoRVVBOkD4HtOCSs2mrr3U0pNPCIouWyzH fCVLa6+vIrjdgXt2a6NuxVp9muJOX3h4Hf4VxkoKzx/Zm3eRzsbho4XZ9lrQ0B93kDR3WX1Japor HNK64TSANGGEcqvYDcauiip468QuDfk07j1XeSnqo7yyifdCJ3M1OkA2AV6LpylqJj49ydUuaMvA eu7LHYqaURPp2Oe8ZAecqYprBCNXh04GTjfuoT1lBSwReBSxPdI8AN09l2q6xkT2U9LDGZnDJGj5 VYqKuC20fizRt1HgNHdc6Mi6U5dW0zSNR0hw7KhLRG23WMvke6gedmfwHsvSDSNgR6J5SKSEIQUs JoQhf//V+vIQeEk8pFLOAkDkoKRUHaXNLHt1NPZeZqaeOp6igtY1Gmj+Mg+av9TTmC0+zxHT4zhH 8LflC5++qe3WprKWGSUsaGsLWnA9Ss+7x3CVrJGV7pS9mfCiHyn1VyjqJqGysEET5qtw+N+OCrsV LV3Cnhjq3lkbfikxy/0WlPBFURmKRmY8AYKwH1UFp6ge50QZC6PS1YdRS3C4Tm5Oa5kL36Tgb6VZ prfTvujaez1ErA5v7V5zyrDZ2wdRTNmDpGwAMAJ5XO4R0kVaHR07gS3Ib6lSMNUfAkdTvY1p/CKa StFcJGuw/wATBz5KzXvjud18KefwooBnY8lbluqYZoNMWXBu2ohF2jdLbJQ0DU1uQfVcrGwuoI5p 5S6R44ytNCEIQhCEIX//1vryEIPCSEJFRO26jrwlrXOobJJCfBfoeODjhYNGJW9WuNRK2R5j2c3s vRvjbIQHNBwe4XMiN2qDbB3LBzhENPDCMsibHq423XZukNBZpO++lUpbvTQ3OK3uJMrxnbt9V1rb jFQQiSYZB4aOSqrWW++QNmMYe1p/VyCrFVV0lvga2YBsZw1rW9lLEQgM9JCx5c3IwMZVCC1U9VUe 85YnRSE/ExxWk6np5HNkcyNxb8vmuU1fTQ1gpXPzI/cDHCmKKATeK2IB/OrC5Cy0IlM5j+I857q4 yFkQ0sYGA+Sq3Zz47ZMWuDfhwCVXsFAYaCGZ8j3OO+CdgtdCXdCEIQg8oK//1/roTQmjI8kgN0kK Ljgpas9lBwykRhVquCSpj8Js7ogedI3KxPd8Vs6ipTC57jK06tRyvUAZBdxuvLdT3KW0XmmqIRqd IzDgTspWm91VVQVr5sOdE3LT5Z7K/QONJ0/7UCXyOaX5J7rChLmXakq3u8SWVpc4n/2VrqCreLhE cD93hbttpY6G2wiMZMjdbifNYFLdJq2pur52tcIW4YCOFapnSG40FMJXNZ4Wp2O65dRV9TLWut7J DHGxurLeSinjl8Ogq3VDyZDp09sBVnVs0vUk8gIbo4GMr18EhfGHEfM3KmcY33TDcg/Reb6nrZI5 IKcD4CcnflaVnr3VYawxhjWtwACtRCfZJCCUZQg7r//Q+vFJPKEihSO4wlhf/9k= ------=_NextPart_000_0106_01C7268C.5EC675D0--