I have been using black suede leather from Tandy Leather.  It is the least reflective cover I have found and only about 10 bucks.  Check out your local store for complete hides.  Sometimes it is hard to find one large enough without flaws, when you do buy a couple, since they fade.  Keep that in mind when you install it, so you can easily replace it after a couple of years.  Looks pretty good too and NO Reflections.  

 

Steve Colwell   (just ordered all the panel goodies for our Legacy at OSH)