Mailing List lml@lancaironline.net Message #31238
From: Don Barnes <don@cellarideas.com>
Sender: <marv@lancaironline.net>
Subject: Report of my accident
Date: Tue, 16 Aug 2005 21:48:31 -0400
To: <lml@lancaironline.net>
Hi All,

It is very hard to write this because I lost a plane I was very attached to and enjoyed more than I can describe. I built that plane over three years and ate slept and breathed it. As hard as it is I feel I owe it to the group, many of who I know and talk with, to describe the events leading to my engine-out.

In the initial set-up and prior to first flight the engine monitor was never set-up. I did that myself later and the fuel gauges were not properly calibrated. For that reason I NEVER flew more than 2.5-3 hours without topping both tanks and not flying greater than one hour unless I could see gas in the tank. That was an indication of half fuel. I had fueled up earlier in the week and logged 2.5 hours which I had entered in my log book Friday and prior to flying Sunday morning knew (in my mind) I had 1.5 hour fuel on board for a less than 30 minute flight where I intended to top-off. I selected the right tank to fly out on and about 20 minutes into my flight and ten miles out reported my position a minute or so later the engine quit and I selected left tank, it ran for a few moments and quit again. Even in my glide down I never thought I was out of gas. But I was. I thought it over and over later and those 2.5 hours were flying around 3000 feet where my burn is 22 GPH average vs. 15 GPH up high. I totally miscalculated from a false sense of security. And had burned 50 gallons. Not enough left for 8 more miles. Totally my fault and I accept full responsibility. However, I will not accept any criticism as I was always flew carefully and said that this would never happen to me. I flew conservatively and really watched my burns. It can happen to others when you don't think everything out and let your guard down. I am paying for this with the loss of a dream and that should be enough.

The things I did right was to identify a dead engine early, pull the prop and get it into a 120 KIAS glide. I identified a spot and when I realized it was rising above in my view I chose another. That one stayed fixed and I was sure I'd make it. I flew the line and resisted temptation to pull up. And coming over the many ravines and oak groves I kept wanting to pull up, but I said out loud "120" and kept flying the line. The last moments I flew over the tops of a grove of oaks dropped down to begin a shallow climb up the hill where I landed and flew it between two oak trees and dropped again to clear a power line then slowly added back pressure to slow the rate of decent so I could get a soft touch down and not drop it in. At no point did I ever think dropping the wheels would be a good idea, and in hindsight I would advise any Lancair pilot to keep the wheels up unless you have a runway underneath you. It'll save your energy and reduce the amount of damage.

I owe my life to Josh Brungardt and all the training I did. I knew after 12 hours with him and all the power pulling he did along with his "land it" commands I had a good feel for the plane. I think everyone flying these planes should be prepared for an engine out and not afraid of one. I NEVER thought I'd ever have one, but always knew I'd handle it OK. And I did.

The good news is I got out without a scratch or bruise. My plane has some minor damage and will easily be repaired, but I don't have it in me to do it. My wife is beside herself and I must honor her feelings and get away from high performance aircraft and let the plane go. I am distraught beyond words. This plane meant so much to me and I will miss it. I will fly again, but later when it's right for both of us. I also feel I let this community of Lancair guys down with such an inexcusable mistake and for that I am sorry. I appreciate all the kind words and messages I have received. A lot I can not read now nor will I be reading future posts.  I felt I owed you all an explination, but I'm not looking for advice on what I could have done last Saturday. You can only go forward and that's what I intend to do. I really enjoyed being part of this group and wish you blue skies and full tanks.

Most sincerely,
Don Barnes

Image
As Found In the Field.JPG
Subscribe (FEED) Subscribe (DIGEST) Subscribe (INDEX) Unsubscribe Mail to Listmaster