|
"I am sure 8' deep girders will be sufficient." Leon
Moisseiff, Chief
Engineer, Tacoma Narrows Bridge
"If you cant find 20' lengths of All-Thread then substitute two 10'
lengths" Jack D. Gillum, Hayatt Regency hotel "Tea Dance" walkway
designer.
"Sure, it's a little stronger with the window bonded in, but
that small
amount of extra strength is not required. The fuselage is strong
enough even with the big hole in it." Rob Wolf
Rob is correct that the static strength of the fuselage is determined
without the windows BUT the windows do have significant "in plane"
(npi) shear strength which will have an effect on the torsional
stiffness of the fuselage. This, in turn, effects the natural frequency
of the empennage. Making the fuselage less stiff by decoupling the
window reduces the empennage flutter margin. Only analysis and testing
will tell us by how much. Pushing the aircraft faster with bigger
engines and making the fuselage less stiff will eventually result in
structural failure. I know of at least one IV -P that disintegrated in
a 0.63 Mach dive.
Rob may be correct that the structural effects are negligible but his
confidence is unsupported by analysis or testing. I doubt he has the
factory's agreement on this matter.
Prudence, and experience, dictates a less cavalier approach to
structural modifications.
Regards
Brent Regan
|
|