----- Original Message -----
Sent: Monday, August 27, 2007 12:03 AM
Subject: [LML] Re: ES Strut issues
What I take from the
points below leads me to focus on the main gear more than the nose. As
Fred so well described, resonance occurs when the modal frequency of a system
coincides with the frequency of a vibration source. If there is little
damping, then the source can be very small but still result in potentially
catastrophic motion/damage. Perhaps I'm misunderstanding, but it seems
that:
1. Vibration has been observed with various nose strut designs
2. Braking (on the mains) has an influence on the vibration
Though I'm not arguing that the nose strut does not have exhibit resonance
itself, I wonder if the mains act as an amplifier, that if removed would
relegate a nose strut vibration mode to an infrequent or non-existent issue.
I proffer that a small imbalance (due to the wheel or rotor CG not being
precisely on the rotational axis), or uneven brake application (due to a
slightly warped brake rotor) may excite a longitudinal mode of the
strut/wheel/pant. The energy of one or both wheels/struts/pants moving
longitudinally may cause a yawing motion of the fuselage that either simply
loads the nose strut laterally, or also causes the nose strut to shimmy
(energetic nose wheel yaw to strut roll interaction). A modal impact (rap)
test could be used to determine the natural frequency of the strut and damping
of the structure (which I'm guessing is very low), and a simple calculation
would show at what wheel speed an imbalance would coincide with this.
Removal of the wheel pants will reduce the mass, thus driving the natural
frequency up, and potentially out of range of normal landing speeds.
I have no personal experience with this, and offer the above solely as
conjecture. If someone is willing to provide the bird, I may be able to assist
with said rap test. It would have to be in south FL, after October.
Cheers,
- Kyrilian
Skip Slater
<skipslater@verizon.net> wrote:
<snip>
I don't have a taxi speed
that I avoid, though I can get a shaking if I try to brake lightly at low taxi
speeds. I don't get any shimmy at all when taxiing with the brakes off.
<snip>
Shape Yahoo! in your
own image. Join
our Network Research Panel today!