|
Peter Garrison with Melmoth II provided some
interesting studies regarding cooling inlets and outlets. FWIW,
what I took away from his studies is that the radius/lip of the
inlet is critical, the size of the inlet should be oversize rather
than too small, and the optimum method of improving cooling and
reducing drag is through cowl flaps. Peter indicates that with
the proper radius of the inlet there is no drag penalty to a
larger than necessary inlet, as the cooling outlet is regulated
with a cowl flap(s) excess air merely flows around the inlet
undisturbed.
I haven't gotten there yet, but I am working on it. Peter's work
with Melmoth is on the web.
Terry Adams
N51079
KSCK
On 4/28/2011 7:54 AM, Tracy wrote:
Tracy,
Wow!
That is less than 40 sq in of inlet
area! Total!! How much exit area do you have?
You
mentioned a pressure sensor. What pressures
are you seeing at wherever you measure it?
Bill
B
Yep, not
too bad for a 300 HP engine.
The total outlet area is 53 sq in. ,not including some
louvers I put in the bottom of the cowl. The louvers
didn't help at all so I plan to remove them. Outlets as
large as 120 sq in were tried without seeing much change. I
am more convinced than ever that the key to efficient &
low drag cooling lies more in the inlet side rather than the
outlet in under-cowl cooling system installations.
53 Sq in may sound like a small outlet for 300 HP but if you
research the planes that are really going fast and cooling
well at the same time you will find that they have a SMALLER
outlet area than the inlets. I haven't been able to get
there but it IS possible. It usually requires that the
heat exchangers have ducts on the outlet side which is hard
to do unless you use a P51 style cooling arrangement.
My air pressure instrument is a modified EM2 and is not
calibrated in " of H2O or anything else. It just reads out
the converted digital value of a sensor (same as the TAS
sensor) so it's just a relative value. When the reading
doubles it means twice the pressure. Someday I'll get
around to converting the reading to something we are used
to.
Tracy
On Thu, Apr 28, 2011 at 9:42 AM, Bill
Bradburry <bbradburry@bellsouth.net>
wrote:
Tracy,
Wow! That is less
than 40 sq in of inlet
area! Total!! How much exit area do you have?
You mentioned a
pressure sensor. What pressures
are you seeing at wherever you measure it?
Bill B
From: Rotary motors in aircraft
[mailto:flyrotary@lancaironline.net]
On
Behalf Of Tracy
Sent:
Thursday, April 28, 2011
9:08 AM
To:
Rotary motors in aircraft
Subject:
[FlyRotary] Re: Cooling
Inlets
Finally
got around to finishing my cooling inlets.
(pictures attached) Up until
now they were simply round pipes sticking out of
the cowl. The
pipes are still there but they have properly
shaped bellmouths on
them. The shape and contours were derived from a
NASA contractor
report (NASA_CR3485) that you can find via
Google. Lots of math &
formulas in it but I just copied the best
performing inlet picture of the
contour. Apparently there is an optimum radius
for the inner and
outer lip of the inlet. There was no change to
the inlet diameters
of 5.25" on water cooler and 4.75" on oil cooler.
The simple pipes performed adequately in level
flight at moderate cruise
settings even on hot days but oil temps would
quickly hit redline at high power
level flight and in climb.
The significant change with the new inlet shape is
that they appear to capture
off-axis air flow (like in climb and swirling
flow induced by prop
at high power) MUCH better than the simple pipes.
First
flight test was on a 94 deg. F day and I could not
get the oil temp above 200
degrees in a max power climb. They may have
gone higher if the air
temperature remained constant but at 3500 fpm the
rapidly decreasing OAT kept
the temps well under redline (210 deg F).
I have an air pressure instrument reading the
pressure in front of the oil
cooler and was amazed at the pressure recovered
from the prop wash. At
130 MPH the pressure would almost double when the
throttle was advanced to WOT.
That did not happen nearly as much with the
simple pipes.
These inlets ROCK!
Tracy Crook
|
|