In a message dated 5/19/2006 6:45:33 AM Central Standard Time,
marv@lancaironline.net writes:
Though I
have flown an L4 and Columbia with the idea of buying one at
different times, I do not have even an hour in each type, so I have no
way
to judge or compare the different models, let alone discern the
stability
and control nuances - I just knew they were too twitchy
for me. Only a
qualified engineer could legitimately compare the
numbers (derivatives) or
an unbiased test pilot be able to discern
the differences. My opinions are
based upon feedback from qualified
people, including professional engineers
and test pilots who have
flown the Lancairs - and that is as much as I'm
going to say about
that.
Rienk,
Thank you for your reply. Everyone has opinions on this forum about
everything under the sun. Some are qualified by training and experience to offer
their analysis of the facts-- many are not.
You have made some rather serious allegations about the Lancair IVP's
safety record and its aerdynamic characteristics and flying qualities, but
at the end of the day you offer no factual evidence to support these opinions
nor any personal qualifications to support your opinons other than to say "you
have talked to a few people." I hope when you get the Envoy
flying, you and your product do not get flamed based on unsupported claims such
as these. As George Braly and company would say, "show me the data." You have
not and cannot because there is no data to support your claims. If you are
interested in the Lancair accident record, I suggest you visit
www.ntsb.gov or attend the annual Lancair
forum at Oshkosh where the past year's accident and lessons learned are
reviewed.
After building and flying a Lancair IVP for over 3 years and 700 hours, I
can say with some authority that there are no stability/ controllability issues
that I am aware of. As a qualified Lancair instructor pilot and FAA designated
pilot examiner I can say that the aircraft is safe in the hands of a competent
pilot who makes good decisions.
Regards,
Jeff Edwards
Lancair IVP