Jeff,
Congrats
on a successful flight.
I
went back a few posts to have a look at your radiator setup again and it seems to
me that you are going to be short on your water cooling requirements when the warm
weather returns. (I’m northwest of Toronto
and have property near Kirland
Lake so I know winters).
Although
the cubic area of your radiator seems sufficient (575cu-in) it’s shape
(read thickness) is likely your problem. Many moons ago I tried to make a
6” thick radiator work but I soon discovered the air flow resistance impossible
to overcome. Air would simply go around the inlet duct rather than
through it because of the high air flow resistance of the core. The P-51
had a very thick radiator but it was made up of 1000s of tubes (kind of like
soda straws) and you could actually see through the 12” thick rad. Your
rad appears to be standard automotive tube and fin construction, as was mine.
A
tube/fin radiator 20” x 20” by 1” thick is far more efficient
than one 10” x 10” x 5” thick for 2 reasons. Resistance
to airflow (which I mentioned) and, by the time air gets to the back row of
tubes/fins of the rad, it has already been heated up by the tube/fin rows in front
of it. Simply put, the delta T between water and air gets smaller as you
progress from front to back.
If you go through
historical posts, this list seems to have found a practical maximum radiator thickness
of around 2.5”. Again assuming a standard tube/fin automotive style
rad (including evaporator cores).
It is imperative that you
measure your oil temps and water temps in the same place as everyone else,
otherwise, comparisons go out the window. Are you measuring water temps
from the back of the water pump? Are you measuring oil temps at the
bypass block?
Your oil cooler placement
is getting lots of air, the core is not too thick and it is 90 degrees to the oncoming
airflow. It’s going to work well. I hate to suggest it but
you may need a different shape radiator to get the water temps down. Go
back though old posts and look at Eds cooling arrangement and radiator dimensions.
It is functional and can be adapted to your cowl. (You have a nice
big cowl to work with so I’m sure you will get this sorted out.)
NeilK
From: Rotary motors in aircraft
[mailto:flyrotary@lancaironline.net] On
Behalf Of Jeff Whaley
Sent: Monday, December 08, 2008
9:40 AM
To: Rotary
motors in aircraft
Subject: [FlyRotary] Re: Update
... Three more flights, water ok, oil too cool
Mark,
I’m not sure
what the cruise temps are as we have been flying short, tight circuits only. I
think cruise temperatures need to be determined before doing too much else,
though re-installing the thermostat may happen.
What is the
relationship between the water and oil temp? I guess you have stock Mazda
thermostat 195F?
Most of the rotary
world has cheek radiators up front, with the oil cooler going in whatever space
is left. My oil cooler is up front on top of the PSRU with inlets/outlets on
both ends and the water radiator (19x5.5x5.5) is below/behind the oil pan …
two independent systems one working too well the other not well enough …
see attached photo.
Jeff